The Loyalty Paradox: Why Your Most Loyal Customers Are Still Shopping Around
Insight

The Loyalty Paradox: Why Your Most Loyal Customers Are Still Shopping Around

42% of our community have stayed with a favourite brand for five years or more, yet 75% are very or extremely likely to try something new even when they’re happy. This week’s survey looks at what loya

Kaidron Insights Team

Loyalty used to mean finding a brand and sticking with it for life. Our community tells a more nuanced story. This week we asked the Kaidron community how long they stay with the brands they love, what keeps them coming back and what makes them walk away.

The headline is a paradox. 42% have stayed with a favourite brand for five years or more, yet 75% say they are very or extremely likely to try something new even when they are happy. Loyalty is real, but it is earned product by product rather than handed to a logo. Just 4% feel more loyal to brands than to specific products.

For brands, the message is clear. Consistent quality is the single biggest reason to stay at 84%, while reformulation is the fastest way to lose a loyal customer at 51%. Protect the formula, reward the repeat purchase and listen when your community speaks up.

88%stay with a brand they like for a year or more
84%say consistent quality keeps them loyal
75%are very or extremely likely to try a new brand, even when happy
57%have paid more for a brand out of loyalty
51%say reformulation breaks loyalty fastest

Chapter 01

How long loyalty lasts

Once a product earns its place, it tends to stay. 64% have stuck with a brand for three years or more. But a long relationship is not a closed one, almost the entire community remains open to trying something new.

How long do you typically stick with a brand you like?

5+ years42%
1 to 3 years24%
3 to 5 years22%
6 months to 1 year8%
Under 6 months4%

How likely are you to try a new brand, even when you're happy with your current one?

99.5%
at least somewhat likely
  • Extremely likely41.0%
  • Very likely33.5%
  • Somewhat likely25.0%
  • Not very likely0.5%

Straying rarely comes with baggage. Only 14% feel guilty often or always when they buy outside their usual brand, while 52% rarely or never do.

How often do you feel guilty buying a different brand than your usual?

Sometimes34%
Rarely31%
Never21%
Often9%
Always5%

Chapter 02

What keeps them, what breaks them

Quality is the glue. Nothing else comes close. Price and rewards matter to around a third of the community, while habit, convenience and emotional connection trail well behind.

What makes you stay loyal to a brand? Select all that apply.

84%Consistent quality
38%Price
37%Rewards or loyalty programme
18%Habit
18%Convenience
13%Emotional connection

When loyalty ends, it ends for tangible reasons. Reformulation tops the list, ahead of poor service and price hikes. Only 2% say nothing would make them switch.

What breaks brand loyalty fastest?

Select all that apply

Product reformulation51%
Poor customer service40%
Price hikes40%
One bad experience27%
A scandal or controversy22%
Nothing breaks it quickly8%

What's most likely to make you switch away from a brand you love?

A better alternative41%
Quality drop37%
Price increase10%
Bad customer experience8%
Nothing would make me switch2%
Values misalignment2%
“Don’t price hike or needlessly change the formula… we noticed!”

Kaidron community member

51%say reformulation breaks loyalty fastest
40%say price hikes break it just as quickly as poor service
37%would walk away from a brand they love if quality dropped

Chapter 03

Mindset and values

This community is loyal to what works, not to a name on the bottle. Yet once trust is built, it runs deep, 85% would forgive a mistake from a brand they have been loyal to for a long time.

How likely are you to forgive a brand mistake if you've been loyal for a long time?

85%
likely to forgive
  • Somewhat likely50%
  • Very likely27%
  • Not very likely14%
  • Extremely likely8%
  • Not at all likely1%
57%

have paid more for a brand out of loyalty, even when a cheaper option existed. 23% do it often.

Are you more loyal to brands or to specific products?

Both equally41%
Specific products38%
Not sure7%
Neither, I go by reviews6%
Brands4%
Neither, I go by price4%

Do brands earn your loyalty, or do you default to what's familiar?

A mix of both40%
They earn it25%
Depends on the category20%
I default to familiar6%
Not sure5%
I don't feel loyal to any brand4%

Chapter 04

The influence economy

Points and peer reviews shape loyalty, on the community's own terms. 25% actively chase points while 26% will only join a programme if it's free. 73% say reviews, influencers and friends affect their loyalty at least a moderate amount.

How do loyalty programmes affect your purchase decisions?

I only join if it's free26%
Big factor, I chase points25%
Minor factor22%
No effect15%
Not sure10%
I avoid brands that push them2%

How much does social proof affect your brand loyalty?

Reviews, influencers and friends

A moderate amount36%
A lot24%
A little21%
A huge amount13%
Not at all6%

Loyalty shows up at the till and in conversation. 77% count repurchasing as loyal behaviour and 60% count recommending a product to friends.

Which of these count as loyal behaviour for you?

Select all that apply

Repurchasing the same product77%
Recommending it to friends60%
Following the brand on social46%
Buying new launches automatically29%
Ignoring competitor ads11%
None of these describe me5%

Chapter 05

The non-negotiables

Asked in their own words what one thing would keep them loyal forever, the community returned to three themes almost equally: reward me, keep the quality consistent and leave the formula alone.

If a brand could do ONE thing to keep you loyal forever, what would it be?

Open answers grouped by theme, an answer can mention more than one

Reward me with perks, freebies and samples31%
Keep the quality consistent30%
Don't change the formula26%
Keep prices fair and steady18%
Listen and be transparent8%
Loyalty is a promise kept, one repurchase at a time.
84%stay loyal for consistent quality
31%want perks, freebies and samples in return
85%will forgive a mistake from a brand they trust

Turn repeat buyers into lasting loyalty

Kaidron helps beauty brands understand what keeps their customers coming back and what makes them walk away. Talk to us about custom surveys and community insight for your next product.

Book a call

Source: Kaidron community survey, The Product Loyalty, November 2026. All figures are percentages of answers to each question. Select-all-that-apply questions total more than 100%. Open answers have been grouped by theme.

More from Kaidron

← Back to Resources